Sunday, May 10, 2009
Minor details
Tuesday, May 5, 2009
Strong start
I began Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy by John le Carré last week because I love action and espionage films and wanted to know if that would translate to novels. I’ve never specifically read a book for of its genre. If the plot sounds half-way decent, I’ll give anything a shot. But I’ve heard a lot of good things about le Carré so off I went.
The first line is fantastic:
“The truth is, if old Major Dover hadn’t dropped dead at Taunton races Jim would never have come to Thursgood’s at all.”
Great details and questions all in one shot. Obviously Major Dover doesn’t matter much – he’s dead. At the Taunton races, no less! I have no idea what that detail means but the specificity draws me in to the as yet unknown narrative voice. Someone – the voice telling the aforementioned truth – is gossiping or confiding in me, making me want to listen.
So now who’s this Jim? And where or what is Thursgood’s? And where would he be if Major Dover hadn’t dropped dead? I’m rubbing my hands with glee over all the questions waiting to be answered. I don’t want all my information upfront; a little mystery can be enjoyable. (I’m talking to you, Larry.)
I was hooked by the bottom on page 2.
So much information is provided in the three long paragraphs that end at the bottom of the second page. Some is scene setting – the teachers at Thursgood’s who debate over opening the trunk of the late piano instructor, Mr. Maltby – and some are prescient – a child observes that Jim’s arrival indicates he knows the layout of the school. The bombardment of information forces the reader to sort through and decide which details are important and will arise later, and which can be enjoyed and immediately discarded. I like the confusion of swirling information that must be sifted through since that is what the various agents in the novel do as they seek out a mole.
In my novel, I tried to create an active beginning that provided enough information to keep the reader interested but raised more questions to force follow-through. So I chose a moment in the story that is an immediate threat and must be handled before moving forward. This seems to be working so far.
I am trying to balance a driving plot with the emotional journeys of the two main characters so maintaining the action and forward motion of the story can be difficult. When I allow my characters to stop and sit and think and talk for a while, I fear they are becoming boring. When I am running them through shooting sprees, I worry that I haven’t conveyed their fears or emotions enough. Hopefully the back and forth between the active and the passive will even the flow.
(And as a side note, so far, le Carré has maintained his pacing while providing excellent inner workings of characters. His omniscient narrator that jumps from focusing on one character to the next was a great choice. Makes me rethink my POV choice. I originally thought my novel would be omniscient instead of third person. Sigh. I can’t go there right now.)
Monday, April 20, 2009
Details, schmetails!

While I writing the first draft of my novel, I haven’t been too concerned about transmitting a technique I use in short stories to the longer form. Until, that is, I began work on my newest chapter. It’s a transition chapter at best; at worst, it will never be included. But the words need to be written because it is all back-story for my protagonist that will directly influence another character’s decision. Somehow this information needs to be given and the best I could come up with for now is a break in my third-person point of view to a first-person account of his childhood and early adulthood. I might eliminate this chapter during revisions if I can find a better way – dialogue, flashbacks, what have you.
As I was working on the chapter this weekend, I began to offend myself with my liberal use of small details. In my defense, I like to think that well-planned, distinct details can really provide a lot of bang for your buck. One ideal detail can demonstrate a character’s entire world view.
But these were by no means ideal details. They were first draft details. The worst kind.
I have to cut myself some slack. Maybe some will stay in the story. Maybe some are just in there as markers for me to remember how I want a character or setting to be imagined. I just need to push through this chapter to get to the next in which the action picks up again. I’ll fix them during revisions.
This concern recalled a book I recently finished, Kate Mosse’s Sepulchre. Overall, a good book. A biographer journeys to France to research Debussy but is actually searching for her family’s past. A parallel story set in 1891 intertwines with the present. History, France, romance – I’ll take it.
One thing irked me about Sepulchre, a small detail relating to details. In the modern day chapters, especially in the first couple of them, the protagonist is described as pulling on Banana Republic jeans or sporting an Abercrombie & Fitch sweater. Now, I have nothing wrong with these two brands (see this lovely dress and pair of jeans here) except that I can’t really afford them.
What I want to know is why these details mattered.
Our heroine, Meredith, is at the end of her Ph.D., most likely not making a ton of money. We actually learn of her financial woes because she keeps checking her bank account online until her book advance is deposited. So does she spend all her money on name-brand items and subsist on Ramen? Does her adoptive mother splurge on expensive clothes to make up for Meredith’s troubled childhood? After I finished reading Sepulchre, it seemed that there was no answer for those stand-out details.
I assume that Mosse wanted to find strong ways to delineate between the heroine of the present – Meredith – and the heroine of 1891 – Léonie. I felt she had already succeeded in that by her shift in narrative tone. Even though all chapters are in the third-person, Leonie’s chapters feel stiffer and Meredith’s read modern. The sentences are longer and more formal for the past and shorter and chattier for the present.
Mosse must have felt that adding details like Banana Republic and Abercrombie & Fitch would ground Meredith in the present. Those details only served to catch my attention and raise questions that I don’t think the author ever intended as important. It doesn’t matter what brands Meredith wears so long as she is comfortable enough to traipse through a cemetery and search the past for clues.
This is unlike chick-lit, or at least chick-lit about women focused on fashion. Name-dropping about labels is required in those books because that is how those characters see the world. And even then sometimes it gets to be a little much. At least those details are appropriate to the tone of the genre.
These label-specific details stand out in the way I fear my clunker images will: bright and atrocious and remembered after the last page is read. For now, I’ll let my terrible first draft details stand. They are by no means name-dropping details but they are my personal brand of details and way too heavy-handed at this point. They’ll last as long as the first draft takes and then it’s the red pen for them! Unless, of course, I really like one and decide to keep it.
Wednesday, April 15, 2009
When a secret isn’t a secret, but merely a minor plot device.
A few weeks ago I rented Roman de gare, a French film I’ve been wanting to see for over a year. I really enjoyed the movie but was anticipating a resolution to a small detail – a bit of conversation – that was never fulfilled. Despite appreciating the ending, I couldn’t shake my dissatisfaction.Without giving any major plot points away, here is the small detail:
Pierre has agreed to pretend to be Huguette’s fiancé while she visits her parents and daughter in the French countryside. Pierre goes fishing with Huguette’s daughter and when they return, they joke to Huguette that they have a secret. She is infuriated but has to let it go since her engagement dinner has begun.
I fully expected the secret between Pierre and Huguette’s daughter to be revealed at some point in the film. When it wasn’t, I got annoyed. Why would a writer reveal the existence of a secret only to have it remain a secret?
Like Chekhov’s gun, if a secret is referenced in early in a film, shouldn’t the secret be revealed in the end? As a writer, my instinct would be to insert something as loaded as a secret in order to exploit the secret later in the story.
But what about the use of withholding a reveal? Maybe a secret could be as ominous as a loaded gun sitting on the table. The knowledge of the secret could weigh heavily between people and create the tension of the story. A character might need to keep a secret and that could be his goal in the story; if the secret was revealed, that would be a failure on his part. All of these options would be predicated on the author’s aim.
But in Roman de gare I couldn’t see the reason for withholding the secret – until I looked more closely at the context of the secret. The secret between Pierre and Huguette’s daughter was not an important detail, a bit of information to be discovered. It was the mere existence of a secret that mattered, influencing a later confession by Huguette. (She assumes what the secret is and reveals the details to Pierre along with the fact that her daughter would know this information. Pierre says that isn’t the secret, pointing out that her daughter chose to keep that one to herself.)
The secret had become a minor plot device that was necessary for Huguette’s confession to happen. If she hadn’t felt threatened that Pierre had learned something about her she’d rather him not know, she never would have confessed. Her confession brings them closer and justifies Huguette’s actions in the final act of the film. All actions have consequences that lead to new actions that have more consequences and on and on. Viewed this way, the information being kept secret doesn’t matter.
Maybe the fact that I jumped the gun on the whole withheld secret thing says more about me than the screenplay. I do hate secrets so it was an emotional reaction as opposed to a writer’s instinct. And I think I elevated a minor plot device because I expected it to mean more. I have seen small details matter greatly in films before (I’ll talk about In Bruges another time) and assumed Roman de gare was the same type of film. I think in many ways it was, just not with this secret.
So, lessons learned:
One - Don’t assume all movies pay as much attention to detail as others.
Two - Even if the movie does pay attention to detail, don’t get too bogged down in picking which details are the most significant. Trust the author and, if she's any good, all will be revealed.
Three - When I write I know I can’t worry about a misinterpretation of a detail or plot device by my audience. Obviously, misinterpretations will happen. But it does call attention to being as clear and purposeful as possible with my writing. The best I can do is try to make details and plot devices intentional.